Updated 26 October 2026: this article has been updated to reflect the 14 October court hearing.
Apple has filed a federal lawsuit accusing OpenAI of trade secret theft, and the headlines are focused on the rivalry between two of the biggest names in tech. The detail that matters for most businesses is smaller and far more relatable. At the centre of the complaint is a former Apple employee who left the company, kept a work laptop, and used it to keep accessing internal systems for months afterwards. That is not a story about AI competition. It is a story about offboarding.
Apple accuses OpenAI of building its hardware ambitions on stolen information
Apple’s complaint, filed in the Northern District of California, names two former staff members. Tang Yew Tan spent close to 25 years at Apple before co-founding the hardware studio that OpenAI acquired for a reported $6.5 billion. Apple alleges he sent supplier information to his personal email before leaving and encouraged job candidates to bring unreleased Apple hardware to OpenAI interviews as “show and tell” material.
The second name is Chang Liu, a systems electrical engineer who left Apple for OpenAI earlier this year. Apple alleges Liu kept a company issued laptop and, crucially, was still able to log into Apple’s internal systems after departing. OpenAI has denied any wrongdoing, stating publicly that it has no interest in other companies’ trade secrets.
The access control detail most coverage has missed
Most of the reporting on this case has focused on the drama of hardware secrets and Silicon Valley rivalry. The more useful detail sits underneath that. According to Apple’s complaint, Liu retained system access after leaving because of what the company describes as an authentication gap, and used that access to download confidential engineering files while working for a competitor. Apple also alleges Liu advised another employee, still at Apple but interviewing elsewhere, on how to copy files without attracting attention from Apple’s own security team.
Strip away the celebrity names and this is a scenario every UK business should recognise. An employee leaves. A device is not returned promptly. Access is not revoked at the point of departure. Whatever happens next is no longer a hypothetical risk, it is a live one.
OpenAI’s defence turns Apple’s own offboarding gap into a legal argument
On 5 August, OpenAI asked the court to dismiss Apple’s case entirely. Its defence does not simply deny wrongdoing. It argues that some of the access Apple has described as theft was created by Apple’s own systems. According to OpenAI’s filing, Apple allowed staff to use personal iCloud accounts for work, and an Apple manager remained logged into Liu’s personal iCloud account for some time after he left the company, later using it to exchange files and ask him technical questions.
Apple disputes this account. In a rebuttal filed on 19 August, Apple called OpenAI’s version of events “distortion, speculation, and improper extrinsic evidence” and asked the court to let the case proceed to discovery. The hearing on Apple’s injunction request and OpenAI’s motion to dismiss, originally set for 1 October, took place on 14 October. Judge Edward Davila said he was highly likely to grant Apple a preliminary injunction. OpenAI agreed not to use any alleged Apple trade secrets while the case runs, and to collect forensic images of devices belonging to 14 employees. There’s no date yet for either ruling, and neither side’s account has been tested at trial.
What happened at the October hearing
The hearing on Apple’s request for a preliminary injunction and OpenAI’s motion to dismiss, originally set for 1 October, took place on 14 October in San Jose. Judge Edward Davila said he was highly likely to grant Apple a preliminary injunction. OpenAI agreed not to use any alleged Apple trade secrets while the case runs, and to collect forensic images of devices belonging to 14 employees. The judge has the power to enforce that agreement. There is no date yet for the injunction ruling or the decision on dismissal, and neither side’s account has been tested at trial.
One detail from the day before will sound familiar to anyone who has handled a leaver. When the judge ordered early discovery on 13 October, he pointed to a conversation about restoring Apple-owned devices as a reason to worry that forensic evidence could be lost. Wiping a device on the way out can wipe the evidence along with it.
Whichever way the judge rules, the exchange only reinforces the point this article made when the case first became public. Apple’s own offboarding practices are now central to one of the highest profile trade secrets disputes in the industry, alongside its allegations against OpenAI. ChatGPT remains integrated into Siri throughout, since the dispute is about alleged IP theft and has no bearing on the commercial partnership between the two companies.
Why this matters for every Apple fleet, not just big tech
In Dr Logic’s experience, offboarding is one of the most consistently underweighted parts of IT security for growing businesses. Onboarding gets attention because a new starter needs to work on day one. Offboarding often gets treated as an administrative afterthought, handled by whoever remembers to do it once the leaver has already gone.
Under Cyber Essentials, this falls squarely under Control 3, user access control, which requires organisations to remove or disable access as soon as it is no longer needed. A departing employee who retains access to email, shared drives, or DMS (formerly MDM) enrolled devices is a straightforward compliance failure, regardless of whether anything is ever misused.
A basic offboarding process should cover:
- Revoking all account access on the employee’s last working day, not at the end of the month
- Collecting and wiping all company devices before final access is removed
- Auditing shared logins, shared drives, and any third-party tools the employee had access to
- Reviewing whether any personal devices were ever enrolled for email or file access, and removing that enrolment
- Confirming removal in writing, so there is a record the control was actually applied
On a Jamf or Addigy managed Mac fleet, most of this can be actioned within minutes of a leaver being flagged, which is precisely the point. The tools to close this gap already exist for most Apple businesses. What is usually missing is the process that triggers them consistently, every time, regardless of how amicable or rushed the departure is.
The broader lesson for Mac-first businesses
Whatever the courts eventually decide about Apple and OpenAI, the underlying lesson does not depend on the outcome. A retained laptop and a lingering login are unglamorous failure points compared with allegations of stolen hardware designs, but they are the failure points that actually cause damage in most real world cases. Dr Logic recommends treating offboarding as a security control with the same rigour as patching or MFA, and carrying it out on the leaver’s last day.
If your current process for departing staff would not stand up to the scrutiny Apple’s lawyers have just applied to OpenAI, fix it before it turns into a real incident.
Ready to close the gaps in your offboarding process? Talk to Dr Logic about strengthening your access controls.





















